November 20, 2009Many thanks to Sobhana Bhikkhuni for sharing her letters as well as others. Besides, it’s a delight to post some words from a bhikkhuni on this issue.
Metta Forest Monastery
PO Box 1409
Valley Center, CA 92082 USA
I am writing in regard to your letter of November 13, which is posted at DhammaLight.com.
With this letter you have declared that my bhikkhuni ordination is invalid, along with several hundred bhikkhunis ordained at Dambulla, Sri Lanka. I was ordained at Dambulla in 2006 upon the advice of Bhante Henepola Gunaratana, who considered that ordination to be the cleanest and most sound ordination form available.
Also with this letter, you attack the ordinations of the majority of bhikkhunis throughout the world, including in the Dharmagupta. You are opposing the vinayadharas and vinaya committees who spent many months and years analysing the issues, prior to ordinations at Sarnath in 1996, at Bodhgaya in 1998, in Perth in 2009, and many more. You are creating disruption and conflict between yourself and a significant part of the Buddhist sangha worldwide.
I request that you disavow this letter and reconsider your analysis.
With metta, Bhikkhuni Sobhana
Rt 1 Box 218-3
High View, WV 26808 USA
Identity Politics and Zen Buddhism
10 hours ago